Crab Boil with Seasoned Butter

Crab boils bring everyone together around the table with heaps of vibrant seafood and vegetables all seasoned to perfection The seasoned butter sauce ties everything together and soaks into every bite making this a meal everyone remembers long after the dishes are cleared

I made my first big crab boil for a summer birthday and it instantly turned into our go to family celebration dinner The interactive nature of cracking and dipping crab gets everyone talking and laughing

Ingredients

• Water: two gallons acts as the base and gives enough liquid to cook everything evenly
• Chicken broth: two quarts adds extra savoriness that plain water cannot give look for low sodium to control saltiness
• Large onion: cut in wedges brings sweetness and complexity choose firm onions that feel heavy for their size
• Garlic cloves: eight whole add richness and body fresh garlic delivers the most punch avoid any sprouting cloves
• Sugar: one half cup balances the spices with a hint of sweetness
• Old Bay seasoning: one quarter cup brings classic seafood boil flavor use a fresh tin for the brightest notes
• Paprika: one tablespoon adds color and a subtle smoky warmth try Spanish sweet paprika for best results
• Salt: one tablespoon enhances all the flavors kosher salt works best here
• Lemons: two halved add brightness and acidity buy lemons that feel heavy and have thin skin for the juiciest result plus more lemon for garnish if needed
• Small potatoes: four pounds use a mix of red and yellow for creamy texture pick those without sprouts or green spots
• Smoked sausage: twenty four ounces gives hearty bite and layers in smoky savory flavor look for sausage with natural casing for the best snap
• Corn on the cob: six cobs halved so every plate gets a piece opt for sweet corn when in season
• Shrimp: one pound raw peeled with tail on for best flavor and easy eating buy them frozen and thaw right before cooking for maximum freshness
• Dungeness crab: four cooked sections brings sweet briny meat that is the star of the table
• Butter: one cup two sticks for the seasoned sauce use European style for more flavor
• Lemon: one juiced mixes with the butter for tanginess and zip
• Garlic: four cloves crushed for the sauce so every bite carries bold flavor mince them fine to avoid large bits
• Old Bay seafood seasoning: one teaspoon ties the whole sauce together
• Hot sauce: a few dashes to taste optional for extra kick I love a Louisiana style one
• Parsley for garnish: fresh adds a green pop and freshness choose brightly colored leaves

Step-by-Step Instructions

Build the Broth:

Add water chicken broth onion wedges garlic cloves sugar Old Bay paprika salt and lemon halves to your largest stock pot Bring the mixture to a rapid boil and let it simmer for 10 minutes so the flavors infuse together

Cook Potatoes Sausage Corn:

Add the potatoes cut sausage and corn to the boiling liquid Keep at a steady boil for 15 to 20 minutes Check the potatoes at 15 minutes wedges should be almost tender but not falling apart This prevents mushy potatoes later

Prepare Seasoned Butter:

While potatoes are cooking melt butter in a small saucepan over low heat As it melts whisk in lemon juice crushed garlic Old Bay and hot sauce if using Keep the butter warm on the lowest setting so the garlic infuses into the mixture

Add Seafood:

Drop crab sections and shrimp into the pot Boil for exactly 7 minutes Shrimp should turn pink and the crab should be heated through This preserves tenderness and prevents overcooking seafood

Drain and Serve:

Use tongs or a slotted basket to remove all food from the broth Let it drain well Discard the onion wedges lemon and large garlic cloves Spread potatoes sausage corn shrimp and crab over an extra large platter or a lined baking sheet Brush generously with the warm seasoned butter sauce Sprinkle with chopped parsley and serve with lemon wedges and extra butter for dipping

Pin it

My favorite part is piling everything right onto a newspaper lined table with bowls of the seasoned butter The smell alone takes me back to my childhood when crab boils were the highlight of summer evenings and all the cousins would race to grab the biggest crab leg

Storage Tips

Refrigerate leftovers in an airtight container for up to two days The potatoes and corn reheat well especially when tossed in a skillet with the leftover seasoned butter Avoid freezing the crab or shrimp once cooked as the texture changes

Ingredient Substitutions

If you cannot find Dungeness crab try snow crab legs or blue crabs Shrimp can be swapped with peeled crawfish tails if available Replace smoked sausage with andouille or kielbasa for a spicier kick Yukon Gold potatoes work in place of red potatoes

Serving Suggestions

Serve with plenty of lemon wedges extra bowls of seasoned butter and crusty bread to mop up the juices An ice cold beverage or simple green salad balances out the richness Add a classic Cajun remoulade for dipping if you want to get extra

Pin it

Cultural Context

Crab boils hold a special place in Southern and Gulf Coast gatherings The communal spread is all about sharing stories and lingering around the table The signature blend of Old Bay and citrus is a nod to the region’s diverse Creole food traditions

Frequently Asked Questions

→ How do I keep potatoes from overcooking?

Check potatoes at the 15-minute mark. They should be just under fork tender when adding seafood to avoid mushiness at the end.

→ Can I substitute other seafood?

Yes, you can include crawfish, mussels, or clams for variety, adjusting cooking times as needed for each type.

→ What’s the best way to serve this boil?

Drain well and spread out on a platter or baking sheet, then brush generously with the seasoned butter before garnishing with lemon slices.

→ How do I make the seasoned butter sauce?

Melt butter with lemon, garlic, Old Bay, and your favorite hot sauce, then keep warm for brushing and dipping.

→ Can I prepare this dish ahead of time?

It’s best enjoyed fresh, but you can prep ingredients and cooked components ahead; reheat gently before serving.

→ What sides pair well?

Crusty bread, simple salads, or coleslaw make excellent sides to balance the rich flavors of the seafood and butter.